Law Office of John Freeman
Call for a free consultation 866-720-3708


Last week, the controversial Detroit shooting from 2009 finally came to a close. But was justice done?

Tigh Croff was surprised when he came home to find two men trying to break into his home. Croff chased one of the men, Herbert Silas, through his backyard and for two more blocks. After Silas displayed his surrender by putting his arms in the air, Croff told Silas that he was going to die, then shot and killed him. Silas was unarmed.

Croff's original second-degree murder charged was reduced to manslaughter after the court ruled he was "clearly provoked."

This case reignited debate concerning what a property owner can do to protect property. The question is whether Croff went too far? Was a two-block chase and a sign of surrender still a justifiable shooting to protect ones property?

The jury decided it wasn't.

Last year, the jury in this case deadlocked. But after a second trial and only two hours of deliberations, a jury found Croff guilty of manslaughter and using a firearm in the commission of a felony. Croff must serve a mandatory two years in prison for the felony firearm conviction, and he faces up to 15 years for manslaughter.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us For A Free Consultation

For an initial consultation at the Law Office of John Freeman, call 866-720-3708 toll free or send us an email. In an emergency, call 248-918-0790 at any time of day or night.

From offices in Troy, Michigan, we represent clients in all federal and state courts in the greater Detroit area, throughout all of Michigan, and the United States.

Contact us today

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Law Office of John Freeman

3150 Livernois Road
Suite 270
Troy, MI 48083

Toll Free: 866-720-3708
Phone: 248-918-0790
Phone: 313-330-2653
Fax: 248-250-5857
Troy Law Office Map

866-720-3708 - Toll Free
313-330-2653 - Emergency 24/7
248-250-5857 - Fax