Law Office of John Freeman
Call us today to schedule
a consultation.
Local: 248.918.0790
Toll Free: 866.720.3708
24/7 Emergency Line: 313.330.2653

The Justice System: Do You Want a "Cadillac" or a "Taurus"?

In the Justice System, the right to counsel in a criminal case is a cornerstone of justice.  In the 1963 landmark decision of Gideon v. Wainwright, the Supreme Court declared that criminal defendants facing felony charges have the right to an attorney even if they cannot afford to pay for one

However, what that actually means is open for debate.  In the words of a current U.S. Supreme Court Justice, it seems as simple as the difference between a luxury vehicle and an adequate car capable of getting you safely from point A to point B.  Recently at a U.S. Department of Justice event marking the 50th anniversary of Gideon, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan stated that indigent defendants should be provided with at least a "Ford Taurus" defense, but not necessarily a "Cadillac" defense. Justice Kagan explained that "we don't have the resources to make [a Cadillac defense] happen," and even if we did have the resources, "I'm not sure . . . that that's exactly what we should want."

Since the Gideon decision, courts have expanded the right to counsel to juvenile proceedings as well as certain misdemeanor offenses. But many states are struggling to provide indigent criminal defendants with competent legal representation mainly because of insufficient state funding.

In the Justice System in Michigan, the stark reality is that publicly underfunded defense services cannot keep up with the demand.  Our struggling economy has forced people that would have used private counsel in better times to now use court appointed counsel.

As a result, the contrast in Michigan is not between a Cadillac and a Taurus, it is between a $7,500.00 used vehicle and a $500.00 beater with a wooden bumper, a shattered windshield, and trim held together by duct tape. 

In Michigan, compensation for indigent criminal defense lawyers is county-based. This means that each county determines the amount of funding that will be allocated to indigent defense services. However, due to county budget restrictions, most criminal defense lawyers appointed to represent indigent defendants receive inadequate compensation for their services and generally lack the resources necessary to provide indigent criminal defendants with competent legal representation.  Unfortunately, this means that attorneys must either take on more cases than they can reasonably handle well, or many well-qualified attorneys simply do not take indigent cases.

For these reasons, if you or a loved one is currently facing juvenile, misdemeanor, or felony charges in Michigan, it is important that you contact an experienced Michigan criminal defense attorney today, regardless of whether you are in Detroit, Flint, Troy, Kalamazoo, Lansing, Grand Rapids, Monroe, Ann Arbor, or any other Michigan county.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact a Criminal Defense Lawyer

For an initial consultation at the Law Office of John Freeman, call 866-720-3708 toll free or send us an email. In an emergency, call 248-918-0790 at any time of day or night.

From offices in Troy, Michigan, we represent clients in all federal and state courts in the greater Detroit area, throughout all of Michigan, and the United States.

Free Consultations

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy